Archive for June, 2010

I trust Ed Balls to fight our corner, says Stacey McNamara

21/06/2010, 08:46:10 AM

I joined the Labour party when I was 15. Tony Blair had just won his famous landslide victory. I was impressed by his charisma and the effect his campaign had on the national mood. And Labour was part of my community, part of my childhood experience. I’ve always known how central politics is to people’s lives. And it’s important who the party leader is. It was important to me that Tony Blair was the leader back in 1997.

And I think it really matters who the new leader is now. That’s why I wanted to write this article to explain why I am supporting Ed Balls. One of the main reasons I am backing him is because of his economic strength and experience. I feel that his unparalleled economic experience and knowledge can help us be a strong opposition at a time when economics are at the very centre of our battle with the Lib Dem-Conservative coalition. While they are making swinging cuts all around, I believe he has not only the knowledge but the strength of character to resist.

(more…)

Facebook Twitter Digg Delicious StumbleUpon

Monday News Review

21/06/2010, 08:16:10 AM

The Leadership Race

“Ed Balls has hailed himself as a “winner” as he set out why he is the best man to replace Gordon Brown as Labour leader. The shadow education secretary said he had successfully fought the Tories and BNP to secure his Commons seat as he insisted he was “in touch” and a “team player”.” – The Mirror

“There’s always this assumption if you’re a black person who’s done something, that someone has given you a bye. That you’re less qualified than the white equivalent. In this race I’d argue that if anything, with the exception of not having been a New Labour minister I’m more qualified.” –Diane Abbott, The Mirror

“I look at the Labour party leadership election through the eyes of an MP who won a seat against the odds. Labour had its worst result for decades and the Conservatives won. It’s no good pretending otherwise. I want Labour win the next election. But it must for a better reason than merely being back in power.” – Gisela Stewart,  Progress

“I want to learn from Labour in Scotland because the way the party have come back from a difficult result a few years ago is a model and inspiration. As leader of the Labour Party, winning back control of the Scottish parliament would be my first priority.” – Andy Burnham, The Daily Record

Collaborator?

“Public sector workers across the country will be deeply concerned to have a review of their pensions sprung upon them on a Sunday morning – without proper consultation. They will be particularly worried given the comments by David Cameron and Nick Clegg in recent days about their desire for cuts to public sector pensions. The Government must make clear that the findings have not been pre-empted.” – The Independent

“Labour leadership contender Diane Abbott said Mr Hutton would be the Government’s ‘pensions- slasher-in- chief ‘, while Left-wing Labour MP Paul Flynn said ‘collaborator’ was ‘too nice a word’ for him.” – The Mail

Finally

“So we already know what Labour’s broad response to this week’s Budget will look like. But it got me a-wondering: what will their response to next year’s Budget be? This may sound like idle speculation” – The Spectator

“David Miliband, the shadow foreign secretary, has offered a token of support to Tony Hayward after the embattled BP chief executive came under fierce criticism for going sailing around the Isle of Wight.” – The Telegraph

Facebook Twitter Digg Delicious StumbleUpon

The art of opposition: speed kills, seize opportunities, never stop punching

20/06/2010, 02:15:10 PM

Six weeks in, and Tom Watson MP is emerging as the leading anti-government stormtrooper. His latest assault is a series of Parliamentary questions and freedom of information requests, which have forced the government to reveal that it has spent nearly £18,000 on re-stocking the government wine cellar since the election.

The cellars include wine’s most legendary names: Chateau Latour, Chateau Margaux, Chateau Lafite Rothschild and Chateau Haut Brion.  Named as “first growths” in the famous classification of 1855, this is the royal family of wine.

Such wine costs a lot to buy. Hundreds of pounds a bottle. Beyond the reach of ordinary people.

Which seems slightly at odds with the age of austerity and us all being in it together. The very week that George Osborne’s axe is set to fall on schools, hospitals and family tax credits. (more…)

Facebook Twitter Digg Delicious StumbleUpon

Amanda Ramsay sees unspeakable contempt for the unwritten constitution

20/06/2010, 10:27:53 AM

There is no overarching mandate for any one party’s electoral pledges.  Which raises difficult constitutional questions for the coalition. Realising that it is on a sticky wicket, the government fears being bowled out, on any given parliamentary vote, if their fragile coalition starts to fragment.  Hence their plans to bolster their precarious position by abolishing the simple majority vote of no confidence and fixing Parliamentary terms, with nothing less than legislative super-glue.

The old lie: “lies, damn lies and statistics” has never seemed more appropriate than while the sticky mathematics of this hung Parliament betray our new political masters’ contempt for the constitutional rule book.

Erskine May must be turning in his grave. To deny Parliament the safeguard of a vote of no confidence with a simple majority, half of the votes plus one being traditionally enough to drag a government back to the polls at any time not of its choosing, is both a con and a travesty.  Constitutional safeguards exist for good reasons. If a government is too extreme, ineffective or totally irresponsible, what greater protection than the ability to oblige the government of the day to face the electorate and seek a new mandate? (more…)

Facebook Twitter Digg Delicious StumbleUpon

Sunday News Review

20/06/2010, 08:41:41 AM

Where is the Opposition?

Darling warns of the danger of slash & burn - but where are the leadership candidates on the Economy?

“Labour needs to choose whether to oppose coalition cuts because it disapproves of the targets or because it disagrees with the fundamental need for a smaller state. If the latter, it needs a plan for delivering a wide range of services at lower cost. It needs a persuasive defence of the strategic function of government in sponsoring growth and policies to match.” – The Observer

“I am proud of the Labour government’s record in returning the economy to growth. Of the action we took to prevent recession turning into depression. The Tories want us to forget that they supported every penny of our spending until the end of 2008 – only then to revert to type by opposing our support for the economy when it was needed most, in the heat of the financial crisis.Wrong on the recession, and now wrong on the recovery. I fear the Tory budget joins the new European rush for collective austerity.” – Alistair Darling, The Observer

The race to September

“But when asked to describe the position he is now in, with a likely fight to the bitter end with his elder brother, he hints at the strain it is having on their relationship, how he is having to cope with it changing – although, he hopes, not for ever […] How does Ed feel when, for example, David slaps him down in public over his opposition to Iraq or when – as happened during the live debate on Newsnight last week – he talks over him? Mr Miliband says: “It is the ‘new normal’, in the sense that I never thought I would find myself in the position of – never mind being on national television in a debate with him – but being in a hustings with him.” – The Independent

Labour leadership hustings have turned into a veritable love-in for the “I don’t know how he does it” generation, as David Miliband talked of the sacrifices both sexes are forced to make for politics while Andy Burnham admitted to missing his children. Ed Balls even complained that male MPs with young families were less likely than women to be excused late-night votes by the whips.” – The Observer

“As ComRes publishes polling that suggests Labour support is stagnant since the general election at just 30% (Con 36%, Lab 30%, LD 23%), today’s events were mostly focussed around the BAME hustings in Leicester. To coincide with that, one of the candidates made an announcement about the extent of their support from BAME elected members and activists, whilst another wants to see a “diversity fund” established.” – Labour List

“Inside Westminster, though, the strange new politics still does not mean that reality and fantasy are any more connected. Many new Labour MPs are very good. But what Labour describes as its new ‘openness’ means nothing more than that they have five leadership contenders: two brothers, another Ed, the one with the eyelashes and Diane Abbott.” – The Sunday Mail

Looking for the leadership? Turn left…

With 50 hustings and members to please will the candidates lurch left?

“The centre ground is where British elections are won and lost. That was Blair’s great genius in 1997 and that, whether all factions within the Tory party like it or not, is where the fact of the coalition is steering Cameron’s government. Even though the four men in the race were only children at the time they are all, surely, acutely aware of what Michael Foot’s leadership did to Labour in the years after the party lost power in 1979.” – Political Betting

“It is the leftward drift that is more interesting. Interesting because at some point the new Labour leader, whoever they are, will have to tell the party things it doesn’t want to hear. Mili-D’s best line on Newsnight was that Labour shouldn’t fall into the “false debate” that how much a Government spends is somehow a mark of success, rather than what it spends that money on.” – Paul Waugh Blog, The Evening Standard (From Friday but still worth a read)

Facebook Twitter Digg Delicious StumbleUpon

Uncut – first month

19/06/2010, 10:57:57 AM

Labour Uncut is now a month old. We’ve had some fantastic contributions, a great reaction and massively more traffic than we expected.

The whole venture was a spur of the moment thing. It’s more work than it probably looks for the small group of people involved. But we’re enjoying it and we think it’s worth doing.

What do you think? What should we do more or less of? What would you have us do differently?

We’re genuinely interested. We want to produce something people want to read.

Here’s a random selection of some of the better-read posts of our first month:

Goodhart on immigration

Painter on the non-existent centre ground

That Abbott quote in full

McTernan on Trident

Ray Collins forgets to pay lip service

Cheetham: who you calling a loser?

Wegg-Prosser on opposition

Westwood on the Big Society

Hain on Ed Miliband

Joyce: neither Blair-lite nor Clegg-lite, thanks

Nick Palmer on the army of the unaffiliated

Hodges blames the Labour right

Straight outta Corpus

The awesome ruthlessness of Ed Miliband

Facebook Twitter Digg Delicious StumbleUpon

Saturday News Review

19/06/2010, 08:42:35 AM

Ed B begins courtship

Ed Balls makes his pitch to the grassroots

Ed Balls is launching a drive to get more ethnic minority candidates into Labour politics, pledging that as party leader he would devote a proportion of party funds towards boosting their number. The leadership contender plans to set up a Labour party diversity fund to enable candidates from groups currently under-represented to stand for elected office.” – The Guardian

Labour leadership candidate Ed Balls has pitched to the grassroots of his party, calling for greater involvement from members and trade unions. Shadow education secretary Mr Balls said Labour needed to do more to support people from under-represented groups to stand “at every level”. – The Belfast Telegraph

“We must seize the chance of this leadership election to renew the Labour Party from the ground up and re-engage with the communities we are elected to serve. Political aims, vision and policies aren’t enough unless Labour can also be a community-based political party rooted in the communities we represent.” – Ed Balls, Labour Values

McDonnell wins

“John McDonnell has promised to bring in a new trade union freedom bill to tackle British Airways-style legal threats to strike action after winning first place in the parliamentary ballot of private members’ bills. The veteran leftwinger, who dropped out of Labour’s leadership contest last week, is seeking support from the TUC’s general council for the bill, which will have top priority among backbench legislative proposals this autumn. Mr McDonnell’s last bill on the subject was talked out under Government opposition in 2008. Mr McDonnell said employers such as BA had been exploiting “minor technicalities” to “frustrate the democratic decisions of trade unionists”.” – Tribune

(more…)

Facebook Twitter Digg Delicious StumbleUpon

The case for David Miliband, by Alex Norris

18/06/2010, 04:41:07 PM

Our crisis is clear to see: a Conservative and Liberal Democrat government stripping people of the best that a state can deliver for them – from the future jobs fund to free swimming for under-16s and the over-60s.

But our opportunity is just as clear: we have a chance while in opposition to reassert our credentials as both the party of the progressives in this country and the future party of government. These dual goals must be our only priorities. There is no point in being progressives without governing, and no point governing without being progressive. All five candidates address these two points to varying degrees, but only one is sufficiently able to do both: David Miliband. (more…)

Facebook Twitter Digg Delicious StumbleUpon

Mark Fox says the leadership candidates should admit New Labour’s real mistakes

18/06/2010, 02:07:43 PM

For the first time in 13 years Labour finds itself adjusting to the problems and challenges of opposition – and they are real. It’s not just the chauffer driven cars and private office officials that have disappeared. More important – and much harder to overcome – is the lack of easy access to information and data, no longer having an automatic slot on prime time news and, for a while at least, still trying to argue from the policy platform on which they lost the election.

And, of course, not yet having a new leader to provide direction and purpose adds to the problem. These things will sort themselves out in time, but for a while Labour will continue to struggle. (more…)

Facebook Twitter Digg Delicious StumbleUpon

Labour leadership desert island discs

18/06/2010, 10:16:54 AM

Next week sees the start of Uncut’s Labour leadership desert island discs series.  Eight music tracks, a book, a film, a website and a luxury.  One of the Miliband brothers to kick off, depending which gets his answers in first.

It would be interesting to hear your predictions. Will any of them actually just pick the 8 records they like best?  Is there any real chance they will come clean with the Tina Turner and the Mantovani?

Or are they cloistered with their top aides as we speak, agonising over whether Billy Bragg is de rigeur, de trop, passé or just beyond the pale?

And what single book can the boffiny Miliband boys possibly elevate above all others?  All those years of wonking, all that policy. How can they possibly fit it all into one book?  Will they even try?

Two years ago almost to the day, Ed Balls did a dry run when he hosted a one-man show in his father’s Norfolk village featuring “music, readings and reminiscences” which gave a “personal insight into the life of a high-profile politician”. It was titled: “With Great Pleasure”.  Really.

Diane Abbott is the only one of the five who has actually been on BBC Radio 4’s desert island discs programme.  Which raises difficult editorial questions for Uncut: should she be allowed to pick different tunes?  Or obliged to?  Or disqualified? Or what? This playing field is not level.  And modern politics abhors – more than anything – an unlevel playing field.

All contributions gratefully received below.

Facebook Twitter Digg Delicious StumbleUpon